You can choose compassion

Today I schlepped down to the Reference Library for the inaugural Literary Café. Katherine Barber, editrix of the Canadian Oxford Dictionary (q.v.), and prolific Canadiana documenter John Robert Colombo gave short presentations. There followed Q&A from host Tina Srebotnjak and the audience, where I was the second-youngest person in attendance.

Barber was sounding as mediævalist as ever and looked very much more so in a red gown of the sort I would associate with Christmas choral performances, which may be another place she wears it.

Barber and Colombo seated onstage in front of Toronto Public Library slide showing their names and faces

I didn’t take many notes of what the erudite and garrulous, though initially nervous, Colombo actually said; not a lot of it was about Canadian English, one of my things.

BARBER: One of the problems is that Canadians don’t know what are Canadianisms. You’re using Canadianisms all the time and aren’t aware of it. [How many people knew butter tart was Canadian? “About 10%. That’s about average.” (Yet again, Bruce McCall: HE’S FIGHTING FOR YOUR BUTTER TARTS.) She’s got a butter tart on the cover of her latest book, above a double-double.]

[There are about 2,000 Canadianisms in the Canadian Oxford’s 170,000 words.] We sweated blood finding those 2,000 Canadianisms. It’s the work that goes into defining them as Canadian [that’s the problem]. It’s all the other words you choose to put in a Canadian dictionary that you wouldn’t in an American dictionary because we come across them more [as in hockey, curling, figure-skating terms, names for native peoples].

It’s much more than 2,000. But I’d encourage you to coin a Canadianism of your own and get your friends to use it. Though you’d need much more than your friends using it to get it in the dictionary. Canadian English is not “dying,” because Canadians are inventive.

People do always ask me about eh. My mission in this is to prove to Canadians there is more to Canadian English than eh. [Use as a tag marker is not Canadian-specific, but that’s the one that gets all the attention; other uses are and don’t.] An American said to me “I know you’re Canadian because you say [ɛ] at the ends of your sentences.” He couldn’t even pronounce it right.

Q. from Srebotnjak: Why criteria do you use to decide if something’s a uniquely Canadian word?

A. We are constantly reading – books, magazines, newspapers, bus transfers, restaurant menus. [She pointedly did not mention anything electronic at all, much less your own little LiveJournal or whatever you write.] We highlight words that aren’t already in the dictionary. We start with the Concise Oxford, which we call the COD. (We call the Canadian Oxford the CanOD.) It had six Canadianisms, four wrongly defined. [In their database, they can “scroll down” through 75 million “words” (surely citations) and the ones with solely Canadian uses jump out, like arborite.] Then we double-check with other lexicographers that these words really aren’t used in their countries.

Some words are predominantly used in Canada, like rosé sauce.

Q&A

  1. Q. Regional words?

    A. Gotchie isn’t a Westernism, as some people think. Gotch ‘underwear’ comes from Ukrainian. Alberta and B.C. use gonch. Guy Vanderhaeghe from Saskatchewan uses gotch. W.O. Mitchell from Alberta uses gonch. So there’s a line down the middle somewhere in New Westminster.

    When I first moved to Ontario, I was going to a shower and I told my boyfriend at the time I was bringing a plate of dainties. “You’re bringing your frilly underwear?” [No, it means little bonbons or cookies.] Nobody from Manitoba or Saskatchewan could misunderstand that.

    [More on showers.] There’s a Jack and Jill shower or, as it’s called in Thunder Bay, a shag. Imagine those poor British immigrants coming over and being invited out to a shag.

    [Another one is bachelors.] Renting bachelors. There are some wonderful variations. Large bachelors, large bright bachelors, refurbished bachelors.

    Canadians just aren’t aware of the words they use that are Canadian. [And one of the issues is spelling.] If we spell colour with a u, that’ll show those damn Yankees!

    — Isn’t that British?

    — Well, we’re not about to invent our own spelling. Canadian spelling is a mixture or British and American and has been all the way back to the Loyalists, who were American. [She gets angry letters about organize, the original British spelling that the British much later reverted to -ise.] We’re just maintaining former practice.

    A woman wrote in and complained to me about tire. She said: We don’t spell like the Americans. But there’s a place just up the street here called Canadian…. (We just don’t see it written as tyre.)

    Yogourt is only ours. It’s handy because that way it works both in Canadian English and Canadian French, and it’s got a u in it like colour.

    — A u wherever it fits.

    — But people put in a u even where it doesn’t belong, like colouration or honourary.

  2. [I asked about her use of single quotes in her previous book. She said it was OUP style, and told me with annoyance that she had to go in and change double quotes to single. Then Colombo made exactly the same complaint about a book he wrote for OUP. (But it’s a Canadian Oxford book, not a British one!) I mentioned I work with a U.S. technical body that insists it has to use British Oxford English, even though I told them if they want to use Oxford, they can use Oxford American. Barber also politely corrected a mistake I made in my question. And a lady from University of Toronto Press stopped me on the way back and said they used single quotes too.]

  3. I swear I did not plant this question

    Q. from woman: When was signage coined, and why is it used instead of signs?

    BARBER: I’d have to look in the Canadian Oxford Dictionary.

    COLOMBO: I can answer that question. [Boy, could I ever see what was coming.] It was coined by a Torontonian named [in unison] Paul Arthur, son of Eric Arthur. He was the one responsible for Expo 67 and he gave it its complete sort of code of design, with the neogothic typeface [sic – it’s Univers, a grotesk, though gothic is used for that kind of sansserif]. [Coined in 1964.] I heard this from him myself and I’ve included this in one of my quote books.

    BARBER: It’s a perfectly well-formed word, like luggage from lug or baggage from bag.

  4. Q. from man about spellcheckers (no matter what you select, Microsoft Word gives you American English) and apple cider.

    A. Cider means something different in England than in North America; in England it’s a strong alcoholic beverage, but here it just means apple juice.

    There is no real Canadian spellchecker out there, as anyone who’s tried to use one knows. [Well, why don’t you make one yourself? several people ask.] It’s something I’ve been wanting to do for about ten years.

(Pet-peeve questions from soft-voiced pensioners who refused to use the microphone untranscribed.)

The foregoing posting appeared on Joe Clark’s personal Weblog on 2007.11.07 16:51. This presentation was designed for printing and omits components that make sense only onscreen. (If you are seeing this on a screen, then the page stylesheet was not loaded or not loaded properly.) The permanent link is:
http://blog.fawny.org/2007/11/07/trl-en-ca/

Values you enter are stored and may be published.

  

Search for very early blog entries, and for anything else on fawny.org:

  

Information

Other reading

FriendFeed puts everything in one place.

Popular topics

Photographs to look atTypography; graphic design; the death of design criticismLeslievilleTTCCanadian EnglishAccessibility

Archives by date

Just add /year/month/day/ to the end of site’s URL, blog.fawny.org. You can add just /year/month/, or just /year/, if you wish. Years are four-digit, month and day two-digit (with padding zero below 10). For example:

Very old archives are still available.

Archives by category

Copyright © 2004–2014

You enjoy fawny.blog